Personal tools
You are here: Home Research Archived Research Modules Action Enquiry & Dissertation (May 10) Module materials Conversations Results, analysis, Discussion and Impact

Results, analysis, Discussion and Impact

This is a summary of what to do in the Results, Evidence, Analysis, Discussion and Impact Sections of your dissertation / action enquiry

By now you should be clear about what data you will be collecting and have started to collect some.


The next stages are: -
•    The Evidence  - this is a portrait, display and description of your evidence
•    The Analysis of evidence - this is in the form of a discussion
•    Impact  - this is an account of

A. What you have learned

B. What difference you have made.

Portraying the Evidence       

You will mainly be using text to describe the data you have collected. Also consider using:

o    Charts

o    Diagrams

The Analysis of Evidence

 

Guidance on the process of analysis is provided Here:

 

This outlines the description (which you should have in the methods section for the “Steps to analysing the data” including:

    Collating

    Immersion

    Coding

    Sorting

    Hypothesis testing

    Pattern identification.

 

You should evaluate - you need to show weighing up of the research.

    Sources of bias

    Descriptive Validity

    Explanatory Validity

    Reliability of the results

 

You should also

Weigh up the evidence

Verify the evidence

 

Impact

You need to systematically describe the impact of your scholarship:

Use Kirkpatrick’s classification (From http://www.businessballs.com/kirkpatricklearningevaluationmodel.htm)

 

•    Your learning: What new perspectives have been revealed to you?

•    Your practice: Changes to what you do

•    The learning experience of pupils: How has what pupils do and/or experienced changed?

•    The learning outcomes of pupils: To what extent have the standards achieved by pupils been affected?

•    The practice of colleagues or of the school.

Document Actions

Our group is small....

Posted by Hamish Scott-Brown at Mar 31, 2011 05:20 PM
...but highly concentrated :-)

Can I ask those of us that have been engaged o-in the Online community and been keeping up to speed with the timeline (thank you) to enter into the last furlongs and tease out just where we all are and take some time to consider the points above?

We are approaching the last stages........

How has it been? Did the earth move?

Our group is small....

Posted by Willem van der Sluis at Apr 13, 2011 09:14 PM
Hi,

I am in the final stage. Last week I completed the first draft. This week I have met my study advocate and discussed the work. I hope to this Saturday some changes and proofread it once more. Then I hope to send it to the UK. As I mentioned in the other forum discussion, I have swapped some units, because it reads more smooth. I start straight with unit 2, and have put unit 1 as appendix. Then I I have moved unit 5 after unit 7. Hope that it is allowed.

Thanks,
Willem

Our group is small....

Posted by Hamish Scott-Brown at Apr 21, 2011 12:35 PM
Hi Willem,
This sounds like you have it all under control.......one thing that I know you will be considering is the 'flow' of the piece - by moving areas around and units (if you like) this isn't a crime and if you consider your dissertation like the making of a feature film......Sam Mendes will have shot and directed some of the early scenes in 'Road to Perdition' possibly as the last scenes filmed and vice versa.....working on a linear timeline can be helpful when we are carrying out the module but it can sometimes make more sense to consider the flow and the continuity by re-adjusting parts as you see fit......and of course this 'as you see fit' is entirely up to you as the author/editor/director and cinematographer of your epic :-)
Use your judgement everyone.......dont feel that it must always be first scene shot as first scene to watch :-)

Remember when we we are at school or indeed when we teach 'writing skills' we encourage our writers to leave the introduction to the piece until last......that way you can cover all aspects and write an introduction that introduces rather than predicts ;-)

H

Our group is small....

Posted by Willem van der Sluis at May 01, 2011 12:56 PM
Hi Hamish,

thanks!

I getting closer

Posted by Jessica Jacob at Apr 14, 2011 12:25 PM
I still am working on the impact part of the research. I have had a problem with the questionaires and surveys I set up. I haven't gotten much feed back if any.
As for impact they were to represent some impact in finding information for inclusive continuum which is my focus.

I getting closer

Posted by Willem van der Sluis at Apr 14, 2011 04:45 PM
I think if you link that last bit with literature and you end with strong recommendations it should all be good Jessica.

Also maybe you could explain why you didn't get much feedback, was there a reason? I had the same with uninterested SEN students who didn't want to take part.

Cheers,
Willem

I getting closer

Posted by Jessica Jacob at Apr 18, 2011 04:26 PM
Great! Thanks. I will look into that.

best,
Jess

I getting closer

Posted by Hamish Scott-Brown at Apr 21, 2011 12:38 PM
remember of course Jess that its quality here rather than quantity - cliche I know but it still matters.

Impact can be measured not just by the number/size of the damage/impact/results but by how well received/affected/influenced etc your research went - depth is key here

I getting closer

Posted by Jessica Jacob at Apr 28, 2011 01:10 PM
Thank you. That's good to know.

How to present questionnaire and observation evidence?

Posted by stephanie zenonos at Apr 19, 2011 03:26 PM
I'm struggling on how to present the data collected from my questionnaire and observations. Should I construct a table to display the information?
Thank you!

How to present questionnaire and observation evidence?

Posted by Willem van der Sluis at Apr 20, 2011 05:50 PM
Hi Stephanie,

yep, table would be the easiest....it depends a bit on what kind of questions you have asked though...

GRW

How to present questionnaire and observation evidence?

Posted by Hamish Scott-Brown at Apr 21, 2011 12:41 PM
yes no and maybe :-)

tables are great for some things and can confuse and baffle in others

this is about getting fact across to your reader in a visual way?? we're going to talk about this in a phone call later Steph yes?

Have you read Colin Robson's views on displaying data?